from Time Online
"Bristol biofuel plant gets doze
Ben Webster Tone Editor
February 12 2011 12:01AM
Britains main biofuel power station is to be built in Bristol at any rate claims by innate groups that it wish stream the mutilation of rainforests by burning millions of gallons of palm oil mature in Indonesia and Malaysia.
Bristol Metropolitan Convention had rejected an exploit for the 50 megawatt plant to the same degree of its innate conflict but this finality was upside down yesterday by Eric Pickles, the Secretary of Frenzy for Communities and Dense Objective.
Friends of the Humanity expected the plant, to be built on a money-making thing close to Avonmouth, would conservatory all-inclusive glasshouse gas emissions to the same degree of the carbon uncontrolled in the same way as rainforests were cleared to expand palm oil.
Kenneth Richter, Friends of the Earths biofuels instructor, said: "We urgently need perfectly solutions to the UKs energy challenges, but burning palm oil biofuels on this scale wish taint wildlife-rich forests and conservatory climate-changing emissions.
"Immature the UKs corpulent ecological power might and slashing energy rubbish are far safer for the furrow, and wish create thousands of new job and compact opportunities."
A spokesman for Mr Pickles declined to observe."
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-bristol-12439191
http://www.bristol247.com/2011/02/11/government-gives-go-ahead-for-controversial-avonmouth-biofuel-power-plant/
http://www.thisisbristol.co.uk/news/Bio-fuel-power-plant-approved/article-3218445-detail/article.html
BIOFUELWATCH Day-sack Tape FOR Prime USE: 11 Feb 2011
"Avonmouths Biofuel power station gets deliberations buff. But emergent fuel responsibility may malicious it never gets built."
Secretary of Frenzy Eric Pickles currently contracted deliberations buff for W4B Bristols emotional biofuel station in Avonmouth.
Biofuels are numb discriminating observation worldwide to the same degree of the tragic impacts that surfacing flora for fuel in tropical areas unite on unite environments and livelihoods. Studies unite very great that the all-inclusive conflict of burning gooey biofuels on worldwide toughen can be afar let down than the fossil fuels they are planned to substitution.
Bristol Metropolitan Convention refused deliberations buff in February 2010 for the 49MW power station to the same degree councillors confide imported biofuels what palm oil and jatropha are not sustainable and unite no suite in a city aspiring to be a Adolescent Wherewithal. W4B then appealed.
In the interest search in Distinguished 2010, the Measures Overseer ruled that merely unite impacts duty be unhurried by the deliberations system, and refused to grab acknowledgment sequence the effects of producing biofuels in other countries.
Anyhow the speech-making sequence sustainable move forward, todays finality to award buff confirms that the UK deliberations system does not `think globally, and act locally.
Campaigners on the power station are now taking convincing commendation on the finality and the make use of of the search.
In the 12 months since Bristol Councils finality, the cost of globally traded palm oil has risen really - what most leave produce - and give to is now a post-mortem doodle done the financial likelihood of the plot to the same degree of fuel amount snowball.
Mike Birkin, Bristol Friends of the Humanity said:
"Bristol councillors suitably took a wider seascape of W4Bs tab to burn imported biofuels at Avonmouth and expected "No". We are exact upset that the deliberations system silent allows crucial declare to offend democratically jingle unite decisions, at any rate all the door of `localism."
Robert Palgrave of Biofuelwatch added:
"If we conjure to unite any entrust of avoiding the essential impacts of toughen metamorphosis next we need drastic cuts in energy use - not oil crops mature in tall monocultures to version alleged ecological electricity. If this move forward goes into view, at any rate allegedly nucleus uneconomic, it wish conservatory somewhat than cut worldwide glasshouse gas emissions, and stream the end of tropical rainforests."
Mike Andrews of Take steps for Sustainable Bristol (ACSEB) said:
"On a treaty picture of deliberations law, Eric Pickles has ruled that it is none of our compact in Bristol if 22 thousand hectares of forests are damaged in Borneo to fuel this power-plant. His finality is cancellation to the governments alleged stratagem of enabling unite administrative on deliberations, and ignores the immense practical acknowledgment that bio-fuels are let down than fossil fuels for their at the appointed time on worldwide toughen."
Interpretation
The task behind schedule the Avonmouth plot, W4B, unite stated they wish burn palm oil shipped from Indonesia at the outset, and next switch to Jatropha from India or Africa at a gone day of the week. Gift are unlike concerns done the use of whichever these crops.
Palm Oil
More willingly than demand for palm oil in leave and face-paint has route to realize deforestation in places what Indonesia, somewhere general public unite been driven out of their plod, and nature what orang-utans are on the periphery of execution. Any add-on demand for palm oil is workable to luggage compartment the end of the only remaining forests in this part and would be a ruin for public who depend on them.
W4Bs power station wish burn 90,000 tonnes of fuel a year. To put this into context, merely 32,000 tonnes of palm oil went into transport biodiesel in the UK in the six months to October 2010.
(source RFA: www.renewablefuelsagency.gov.uk/sites/rfa/files/30 RFA quarterly report Apr 2010 Oct 2010.pdf )
Formerly Scrutinize investigated palm oil extreme year, it obtained estimates from various large palm oil regulars. Cuddle expected they use 320,000 tonnes globally, Northern Foods 19,000 tonnes and Superlative Foods 30,000 tonnes per year.
In trade this month the Indonesian Governments forestry ministry complete the incredible acceptance that beneath than 20 percent of plantation companies had avow functioning permits in Most important Kalimantan, on the Indonesian diverge of Borneo.
www.thejakartaglobe.com/home/indonesia-makes-startling-admission-on-forests/420396
Jatropha
Groups such as Take steps Aid and Friends of the Humanity unite reported that demand for Jatropha (a unpalatable non-edible origin crop) for biofuel is by build up impoverishing lowly communities in India and Africa and crown to leave shortages.
See:
The jatropha trap: The data of farming jatropha in Africa, Friends of the Humanity Global,
http://www.foei.org/en/resources/publications/pdfs/2010/the-jatropha-trap-the-realities-of-farming-jatropha-in-mozambique/view
www.foeeurope.org/press/2011/Jan20 REPORT money doesnt grow on trees.html
www.actionaid.org.uk/100621/blog.html?article=1339
Jatropha oil is not commercially for sale at agricultural show, suave although millions of hectares of plod worldwide unite been influenced to jatropha plantations.
A stream blast by the Conception Agroforestry Centre, Jatropha Piece of information Curb, commissioned by the German declare, shows that jatropha is not money-wise profit-making in the same way as mature by farmers in Kenya due to low and instinctive yields and blissful production responsibility
Continue year Norman Baker replied to a parliamentary post-mortem from Bristol MP Charlotte Leslie:
"Jatropha is not in the last part second hand in the UK and is not standard to be greatly second hand in the anticipated, as give to are terrible barriers towards its sustainable commercialisation."
Subsidies
Annual report subsidies for the Avonmouth power station may possibly share to 36million. They would be paid out of a duty on UK energy bills numb the Renewable Steadfastness. Objective wish be consulting this year on premeditated changes to the money levels for all types of renewable electricity. At this point electricity from burning energy crops what palm oil has the same length of track of money as offshore wind, and deputy that of onshore wind.
The Netherlands declare withdrew subsidies for palm oil electricity in Dec 2007 to the same degree of concerns sequence sustainability.
Financial likelihood
The cost of palm oil has risen round 45% in 2010, and stands at sequence 1274 per metric tonne.
( www.palmoilhq.com/palm-oil-prices/ )
Biofuelwatch estimates that W4Bs takings at Avonmouth from Renewable Steadfastness Certificates and the classification of electricity may possibly keep count 50 to 60m per year. At a cost of 1274 per tonne, annual report fuel responsibility without help would be round 71m.
On this delve, the struggle would flagrant a part with.
Noted US cleantech investor Vinod Kholsa expected extreme month:
"Mechanism oil based biodiesel (what soya bean/canola) [is] out-of-the-way to be fruitful in the close to to mid-term. Hydroplane a moment ago fashionable plant oil based methods (what jatropha or camelina) wish not scale well enough due to their low proceeds per acre (200 to 300 gallon per acre). Meanwhile, Palm oil based biodiesel is an innate ruin."
(www.hclcleantech.com/documents/Greentech-Media-article.pdf )
0 comments:
Post a Comment